Yeah... It’s not that I disapprove of being excellent at your instrument; just that the brain / imagination can be a pretty awesome instrument too, and now we can express it in previously impossible ways thanks to technology :-)
Ha ! Joking aside, that actually describes a lot of the Hip Hop I love, but I'm not sure that's what the people who come out with this sort of thing mean. "Y'know... PROPER music". Grrr.
Interesting points made. Funnily, I used to say the best music was made in the ‘80s, or came from Minneapolis, now I’m older and wiser I can see there’s a lot of dross came out of both. I think it’s about forming opinions based on biases be they conscious or unconscious
Absolutely... but it's principally that idea of a song having a 'truthful' core that you can only prove or demonstrate by stripping it back to basics that annoys me. I mean, talking about Minneapolis, how much more stripped back could a song actually be than Sign o' the Times ? Technically, that's a one-chord song with no real chorus; by that metric, a disaster - but of course we know it's not.
“Music just isn’t as good as it used to be”. The 90s is underrepresented in my music collection not because the quality suddenly fell off a cliff after the wonderful 80s, but because I had other priorities in life. Similarly, I’m listening to (for example) great new songs from Brazil and indigenous Canadian music because it’s there at my fingertips if I have the time and curiosity (I have both!). Hence your reference to Bandcamp, Tim, is spot on 😊
Preach! ❤️❤️
"I like that imagination can now trump virtuosity"
Roger that.
Yeah... It’s not that I disapprove of being excellent at your instrument; just that the brain / imagination can be a pretty awesome instrument too, and now we can express it in previously impossible ways thanks to technology :-)
“A song is only good if you can sing it and accompany yourself with one instrument - the drums." That's more like it (wrote the drummer)
Ha ! Joking aside, that actually describes a lot of the Hip Hop I love, but I'm not sure that's what the people who come out with this sort of thing mean. "Y'know... PROPER music". Grrr.
Interesting points made. Funnily, I used to say the best music was made in the ‘80s, or came from Minneapolis, now I’m older and wiser I can see there’s a lot of dross came out of both. I think it’s about forming opinions based on biases be they conscious or unconscious
Absolutely... but it's principally that idea of a song having a 'truthful' core that you can only prove or demonstrate by stripping it back to basics that annoys me. I mean, talking about Minneapolis, how much more stripped back could a song actually be than Sign o' the Times ? Technically, that's a one-chord song with no real chorus; by that metric, a disaster - but of course we know it's not.
Yes. The truthful core. Even if that is a detuned piano, a rimshot and tone deaf muttering from Laurel Canyon!!!
I think that’ll be my Alter Ego. I might start with a cover version of the aforementioned Minneapolis genius
“Music just isn’t as good as it used to be”. The 90s is underrepresented in my music collection not because the quality suddenly fell off a cliff after the wonderful 80s, but because I had other priorities in life. Similarly, I’m listening to (for example) great new songs from Brazil and indigenous Canadian music because it’s there at my fingertips if I have the time and curiosity (I have both!). Hence your reference to Bandcamp, Tim, is spot on 😊